Dried or tinned lentils: what should you buy when the cooked portion counts?
Dried or tinned lentils? If you have 20 to 30 minutes and want to pay less per portion, buy dried. If you need lentils in a quarter of an hour for a salad, buy a tin. Always compare the weight of the cooked lentils on the plate, because 100 g dried and 100 g tinned are very different amounts of food.
Dried lentils soak up water and roughly triple in weight once cooked. Tinned lentils are already cooked and sit in liquid, so the net weight on the label includes the water. That is why the price per kilo on the pack does not tell you what a portion costs.
The two recipes below the first section show both cases: a red lentil soup from dried lentils for four, and a tinned lentil salad with feta for two. Varieties have their own guide, red or green lentils. Here we look at the form of the pack.
Red lentil and carrot soup
Dried red lentils break down in 20 minutes and thicken the soup on their own. Enough for two days.
Ingredients
- Dried red lentils200 g
- Carrots2
- Onion1
- Garlic2 cloves
- Chopped tomatoes 400 g1 tin
- Vegetable stock1 l
- Ground cumin1 tsp
- Rapeseed oil1 tbsp
- Lemon½
Method
- Rinse the lentils in a sieve. Chop the onion and coarsely grate the carrots.
- Soften the onion and carrots in the oil for 5 minutes. Add the garlic and cumin and cook for another minute.
- Add the lentils, tomatoes and stock. Bring to the boil, lower the heat and simmer half-covered for 20 minutes, until the lentils fall apart.
- Blend the soup smooth or leave it chunky. Season with salt, pepper and lemon juice.
- Cool the portions for the next day and refrigerate them within 2 hours.
Tinned lentil salad with feta
Dinner in 15 minutes with no lentils to cook. One tin makes two portions.
Ingredients
- Tinned lentils drained1 tin
- Feta100 g
- Cherry tomatoes200 g
- Cucumber1
- Red onion½
- Parsley a handful
- Olive oil2 tbsp
- Wine vinegar1 tbsp
- Mustard1 tsp
Method
- Drain the lentils in a sieve and rinse them under cold water. Leave them to drip dry.
- Halve the cherry tomatoes, dice the cucumber, finely chop the onion and the parsley.
- Shake the olive oil, vinegar, mustard, a pinch of salt and some pepper in a jar.
- Toss the lentils with the vegetables and dressing. Crumble the feta on top. Taste before adding salt, because feta is salty.
Tip Dried green lentils give a firmer salad. Cook 100 g for about 25 minutes and let them cool.
How do dried and tinned lentils compare in a table?
The table sets the two forms against the points that decide a purchase. It assumes dinner for two to four people, so one tin or one bag spread over a few meals.
| Criterion | Dried lentils | Tinned lentils |
|---|---|---|
| Cost per kilo cooked | Usually lower, since you spread the bag price over about three times the cooked weight | Higher, because you also pay for the water and the cooking; use the drained weight |
| Time | Red about 15–20 minutes, green and brown about 25–35 minutes | A few minutes: drain, rinse and go |
| Taste and texture | Red breaks down into a thick sauce, green and brown hold their shape | Soft, even, often slightly salty from the liquid |
| Best uses | Soup, dal, sauces, pastes, meatless meatballs | Salads, quick weeknight dinners, sandwiches |
| Storing unopened | Dry cupboard in a sealed container, for a long time | Dry cupboard until the date on the tin |
| After opening or cooking | Cool cooked lentils and keep them in the fridge | Move leftovers to a container and keep in the fridge |
If you cook two lentil dishes in a week, buy both. Dried goes into the weekend soup, and the tin rescues the evening when time runs short.
USDA FSIS: Shelf-Stable Food SafetyHow much cooked lentil does a bag of dried lentils give?
According to USDA FoodData Central, 100 g of dried lentils has about 350 kcal and 100 g of cooked lentils about 115 kcal. The energy stays the same and only water is added, so 100 g dried gives roughly 300 g cooked. That is our editorial estimate from those two figures, and a different variety may vary a little.
A typical tin holds 400 g net, and after draining a little over half of that remains. When a recipe asks for 250 g of lentils, check whether it means dried or cooked before adding them to the list.
- Dried lentils: the soup recipe on this page uses 200 g for four people.
- Tin: one tin is enough for the salad for two.
- Drained weight: look for it on the label, since Regulation 1169/2011 requires it for solid food in a liquid.
- Salt: the nutrition table gives salt per 100 g, and tinned lentils often contain more than dried.
The list covers one dinner, so for a bigger household simply buy more tins or a larger bag.
USDA FoodData CentralRozporządzenie (UE) nr 1169/2011 w sprawie przekazywania informacji na temat żywnościHow do you work out the cost of cooked lentils from a bag and a tin?
EU Directive 98/6/EC requires shops to show a unit price, but for a tin it can refer to the weight with liquid or the drained weight, depending on the label. So do your own sum: the price divided by the weight of cooked lentils.
The example below uses made-up prices, only to show the method.
- For dried: multiply the bag weight by 3 to estimate the cooked weight.
- Divide the bag price by that weight in kilos.
- For a tin: take the drained weight from the label and divide the price by it in kilos.
- Compare both results with how much time you have tonight.
Example: a 500 g bag of dried green lentils costs £1.20. Cooked, it gives about 1.5 kg (500 g × 3), so a kilo of cooked lentils costs 1.20 ÷ 1.5 = £0.80. A 400 g tin costs £0.70 and the drained weight is 240 g, so a kilo of cooked tinned lentils costs 0.70 ÷ 0.24 = £2.92.
If you need one portion for a salad tonight, the extra for the tin may be worth the 30 minutes. If you are making a soup for several days, the bag wins. There are more sums like this in our guide to price per kilo across pack sizes.
Dyrektywa 98/6/WE w sprawie ochrony konsumenta przez podawanie cen produktów (cena jednostkowa)When should you choose dried lentils and when tinned?
Time, the dish and how much you will eat over a few days decide it. Here are two short pointers for a typical week for two to four people.
When to buy dried lentils
Choose dried when you are making a soup, dal or sauce and have half an hour. Red lentils cook fastest and collapse into a thick sauce, with no soaking needed.
- lentil soup and cream of lentil,
- dal with coconut milk,
- a sauce in place of mince, as in lentils in a meat-free pasta sauce,
- a batch for several dinners from one pan.
When to buy tinned lentils
A tin works when dinner has to be ready in 15 minutes or when the lentils should stay whole, as in a salad.
- a salad with feta and vegetables,
- sandwiches and wraps,
- a quick bowl with rice and vegetables,
- a topping for soup when time ran out.
How do you use up one pack of lentils over a week?
One bag of dried lentils covers several dinners for two, so the idea for the week starts with a plan, not with the shelf. Cook the whole amount at once and split it into portions you will use within 3–4 days, in line with the USDA FSIS guidance for leftovers.
The plan below assumes a 500 g bag of dried lentils, which our estimate puts at about 1.5 kg once cooked. That is enough for a soup for four with some left for extras.
- Day one: red lentil and carrot soup for four, from the recipe on this page.
- Day two: a portion of cooked lentils in a bowl with rice, an egg and vegetables.
- Day three: stirred into a tomato sauce in place of part of the meat.
- Day four: sandwiches or wraps with lentil spread and cucumber.
- Freezer: whatever you will not eat within 3–4 days goes into separate portions, labelled with the date.
If you know the week will leave you short of time, add one tin for an emergency evening. It costs more, but it saves the plan and does not end up as wasted food.
USDA FSIS: Leftovers and Food SafetyHow do you store dried, cooked and opened lentils?
Keep dried lentils in a sealed container in a dry cupboard. Use tins in date order and set aside any that are dented or bulging. Once opened, move the rest into a glass or plastic container. Treat an opened tin like leftovers: USDA FSIS advises using them within 3–4 days in the fridge.
Cool cooked lentils and refrigerate them within 2 hours of cooking. USDA FSIS says leftovers keep 3–4 days in the fridge and 3–4 months in the freezer. If you cook a large batch, spread it in shallow containers so it cools faster.
The Polish National Centre for Nutrition Education (NCEZ PZH) puts pulses in the protein quarter of its healthy plate. Chilled lentils make a handy packed lunch in a sandwich or a vegetable bowl.
USDA FSIS: Shelf-Stable Food SafetyUSDA FSIS: Leftovers and Food SafetyNCEZ PZH: Talerz Zdrowego ŻywieniaHow do you add dried and tinned lentils to your BuyNest list?
Add the form and weight to the item name: dried green lentils 500 g or tinned lentils, 2 tins. Whoever is at the shelf knows which to grab, and everyone in the household sees a shared list in the app.
We put the ingredients for both recipes, the soup and the salad, on one list: the ready shopping list for lentil soup and salad. You can import it in a few steps.
- Open the ready list on this page.
- Scan the QR code, or tap the import button on your phone.
- Remove what you already have and adjust amounts to your household.
- Assign items to shops and share the list with the people you live with.
More side-by-side guides are in food comparisons, and dinner ideas in BuyNest recipes.
Dried and tinned lentils: soup and salad
- Pulses
- Dried red lentils500 g
- Tinned lentils 400 g tins2 pack
- Tins and stock
- Chopped tomatoes 400 g tin1 pack
- Vegetable stock1 l
- Vegetables
- Carrots500 g
- Onion2 pcs
- Red onion1 pcs
- Garlic bulb1 pcs
- Cherry tomatoes250 g
- Cucumber1 pcs
- Parsley bunch1 pcs
- Lemon1 pcs
- Dairy
- Feta200 g
- Spices and oils
- Ground cumin1 pack
- Wine vinegar bottle1 pcs
- Mustard jar1 pcs
Frequently asked questions
Do dried lentils need soaking?
Red lentils and most small varieties do not need soaking. Green and brown do not either, but they cook for longer. Rinse them in a sieve to remove dust and any small stones.
How much dried lentil replaces one tin?
A 400 g tin has a little over half that weight once drained, so about 240 g of cooked lentils. Around 80 g dried gives a similar amount cooked, as the weight roughly triples. That is an editorial estimate, so check the drained weight on your tin.
Should you rinse tinned lentils?
Yes, rinse them in a sieve under cold water. This washes away some of the liquid and salt. You can add the liquid to a soup, but it will taste saltier.
How long do cooked lentils keep?
USDA FSIS gives 3–4 days in the fridge and 3–4 months in the freezer for leftovers. Cool them and refrigerate within 2 hours of cooking. If the smell or taste seems off, do not eat them.
Are tinned lentils less healthy?
The nutrition is similar, and the main difference is usually the salt in the liquid. Check the nutrition table and choose a short ingredient list. For dietary questions, ask a dietitian or your doctor.
Dried or tinned lentils: choose by how much time you have tonight and how many dinners you want from one pack. Write the form and weight on your list. Import the ready list into BuyNest and compare only the price of a cooked portion in the shop.
Open the ready list in BuyNestSources
- Rozporządzenie (UE) nr 1169/2011 w sprawie przekazywania informacji na temat żywności
- Dyrektywa 98/6/WE w sprawie ochrony konsumenta przez podawanie cen produktów (cena jednostkowa)
- USDA FoodData Central
- USDA FSIS: Shelf-Stable Food Safety
- USDA FSIS: Leftovers and Food Safety
- NCEZ PZH: Talerz Zdrowego Żywienia
Take the shopping into BuyNest
BuyNest is on iPhone and Android. The app has no ads, including on the free plan.
